‘It is the criticism that has dated’

Today “Zooey” does not seem too long, and is arguably Salinger’s masterpiece. Rereading it and its companion piece “Franny” is no less rewarding than rereading The Great Gatsby. It remains brilliant and is in no essential sense dated. It is the contemporary criticism that has dated. Like the contemporary criticism of Olympia, for example, which jeered at Manet for his crude indecency, or that of War and Peace, which condescended to Tolstoy for the inept “shapelessness” of the novel, it now seems magnificently misguided. However—as T.J. Clark and Gary Saul Morson have shown in their respective exemplary studies of Manet and Tolstoy7—negative contemporary criticism of a masterpiece can be helpful to later critics, acting as a kind of radar that picks up the ping of the work’s originality. The “mistakes” and “excesses” that early critics complain of are often precisely the innovations that have given the work its power.

New York Review of Books


One thought on “‘It is the criticism that has dated’

  1. rudolfo nasorosso says:

    You do realise that with Alison Croggon having shut up shop combined with your lamentable lack of blog productivity, many of us have been forced to down loading pornography instead.

    Please remedy this.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *